Pizza restaurants

Jimmy's UNA Pizza

4.8 195 reviews 3:00 AM - 8:30 PM 4711 Pollack Ave, Evansville, IN 47714, United States

Discover this place

Located at 4711 Pollack Ave in Evansville, IN, Jimmy's UNA Pizza has quickly become a beloved local gem. Customers rave about the warm atmosphere and exceptional service. Jory Ellison shared a heartwarming experience, highlighting how attentive the staff was, even personally delivering orders to cars. This kind of service is a common theme in many reviews.

The pizza itself garners high praise. Patrons describe the crust as crispy and flaky, with generous toppings that include a rich variety of vegetables and meats. Nettie Daum was thrilled with her first visit, indulging in a pizza topped with leftover stromboli ingredients, and found the portions to be satisfyingly large.

First-timers, like Danielle and Taylor Gammon, echoed the enthusiasm with simple but heartfelt reactions, underscoring Jimmy's as the best pizza in Evansville. The cheese bread is also a highlight, adding to the comforting experience. Despite its small interior, the passion for quality and hospitality shines bright, making Jimmy's UNA Pizza a must-visit for pizza lovers.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner

Atmosphere

Casual
Quiet

Crowd

Family-friendly

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Jimmy's UNA Pizza before visiting.

Reviews for Jimmy's UNA Pizza

4.8

195 reviews

100%

Review highlights

Based on 195 reviews

Jimmy's UNA Pizza has garnered consistently positive feedback for its welcoming atmosphere and attentive customer service, often highlighted as warm and accommodating. Patrons frequently mention the friendly staff’s genuine hospitality, including thoughtful gestures that enhance the dining experience. The quality of the food stands out, with numerous reviews praising the fresh ingredients, flavorful combinations, and well-prepared crust, described as crispy and flaky. Portions are noted as generous, providing good value and satisfying leftovers. While the space is small and primarily suited for takeout, customers appreciate the efficient service and the overall inviting environment. Collectively, the reviews reflect a strong reputation for delicious pizza, great customer care, and an enjoyable visit at this Evansville establishment.

Jory Ellison

Jun 26, 2025

I never leave reviews. But amazing atmosphere and service. I had my young daughter with me and the gentleman walked my order out to my truck without me asking. And they wouldn’t except a tip! They were just happy to serve. Pizza was amazing as well. Highly recommend.

Nettie Daum

Jun 18, 2025

Hospitable; great value; freshly prepared, generous portions; and, added bonus: enough overflow of stromboli ingredients to top my cheese pizza. We're very pleased with our first visit to Jimmy's and that we have plenty of leftovers for several, delicious lunches.

Danielle

Jun 16, 2025

Just tried for the first time I haven’t even finished my first slice and all I can say is wow!

Michele Bertalan

May 26, 2025

First time customer. Pizza is tasty. The crust is crispy/ flaky, lots of vegetables and meat. The cheese bread was good too.. I would recommend and would go back again.. this place is very small inside, pick up and go .

taylor gammon

May 01, 2025

I tried for the first time yesterday , 100% would recommend to anyone. best pizza in evansville and the woman working was so kind! i am definitely going again soon!

Blackburn Family

Apr 23, 2025

Bill Metcalfe says to tell you it’s the best pizza in the WORLD...and he’s had pizza in Italy, Chicago, NYC...nashville lol...

Adam B yep

Apr 04, 2025

My family has never had a problem with anything that we have ever ordered from jimmys. Highly recommend for delicious storm ,sandwich's and pizza.

Joe Spinks

Mar 26, 2025

Called to get a pizza no one answered so I thought they where closed seconds later the very nice lady called me back now that's service.The pizza was the best Una pizza I have had excellent and plenty of toppings.Thank you for a great experience.